Should You Repair or Replace Roof Shingles?

Should You Repair Or Replace Roof Shingles?

Orlando Roofing Company 

As a reliable Orlando roofing company, Castle Roofing Group understands that every leak, missing shingle, or strange roof noise makes your heart sink. Is it a quick fix or something more serious? When deciding between roof repair and replacement, there are several things every Central Florida homeowner should carefully weigh.

What to consider when deciding if you should repair or replace your roof

Here’s a guide to help Central Florida homeowners weigh repair vs. replacement options:

1. The Age of Your Roof

Just like humans, roofs have a lifespan. If your roof is near the end of its expected life (typically 20-25 years for asphalt shingle roofs), replacement is usually the wiser long-term investment.  If you’re unsure of your roof’s age, there are ways to estimate it. You can reach out to previous homeowners, check building permit records, or schedule a professional roof inspection. Patching up an aging roof can lead to repeated problems and higher costs down the road.

2. The Extent of Roof Damage

  • Minor Issues: If it’s a few missing shingles from recent storm damage or a minor leak in an isolated spot, a skilled roof repair can likely solve the issue.
  • Major Damage/Active Leaks: Multiple leaks, extensive shingle damage, sagging rooflines, or underlying problems with the roof’s structure usually point towards needing a full replacement. Look out for water stains in your attic, curled or buckling shingles, and granules from shingles collecting in your gutters. These are telltale signs of significant wear and tear.

3. The Type of Roof

  • Asphalt Shingles: Most common in Florida, they often can be partially repaired. Replacement involves removing old shingles and installing new ones.
  • Tile/Metal: These roofs are often repairable with cracked tiles or damaged sections replaced. A full replacement is more complex.

4. Roof Replacement Cost

While a repair seems like the cheaper option upfront, it’s not always true in the long run. Here’s why:

  • Hidden Costs: Small repairs can’t address widespread wear and tear or aging components within your roof system. More problems often surface soon after.
  • Value and Longevity: A full replacement provides a brand-new roof designed to last many years. This peace of mind and increased home value often outweigh the initial expense.
  • Insurance Considerations: Don’t forget to factor in your homeowner’s insurance. If the damage is caused by a storm or other covered event, your policy might pay for a significant portion of a full replacement (minus your deductible).

5. Long-Term Plans: How long do you plan on staying in your home?

  • Staying Put: A new roof is a major investment, protecting your home for years to come.
  • Selling Soon: A new roof adds value, but buyers still may want concessions. Repairs might be sufficient if you need to sell quickly.

6. Roof Energy Efficiency

Full replacement is the chance to:

  • Upgrade Insulation: Reduce attic heat gain and lower your cooling costs.
  • Choose Energy-Smart Materials: Lighter-colored shingles reflect more sun, further reducing your home’s energy load.

7. Building Codes and Requirements

Current Florida building codes might necessitate a full roof replacement if your existing roof has two or more layers of shingles.  A professional roof inspection from a company like Castle Roofing Group will help you understand how building codes apply to your specific situation.

When Should I Replace My Roof?

You should replace your roof if it’s nearing or past its expected lifespan, has multiple leaks or shows signs of water damage in your attic, has extensive shingle damage (missing, cracked, or buckling), or if it doesn’t meet current building codes or has too many layers of old shingles.

Best Time of Year to Replace Roof Shingles?

Central Florida homeowners often wonder when to tackle a roof replacement. Ideally, avoid hurricane season (June – November) due to unpredictable weather and high contractor demand.  Our mild fall, winter, and early spring seasons provide optimal weather conditions for roofing work.

DIY vs. Professional Roof Repairs and Replacements

While DIY projects can be satisfying, roof repairs and replacements carry significant safety risks. Improper installation of roofing materials, flashing, and sealants can lead to even more extensive damage. For both your safety and to ensure proper installation that preserves manufacturer warranties, always trust a professional roofing company like Castle Roofing Group.

Benefits of a New Roof

  • Protection: A new roof with modern materials provides increased hurricane resistance and better protection against Florida’s harsh sun and storms.
  • Energy Savings: Upgrading insulation and choosing lighter-colored shingles can reduce attic heat, lowering your cooling costs.
  • Curb Appeal: A fresh roof instantly updates your home’s appearance, boosting your pride of ownership and value if you’re considering selling.

Roofing Companies Near Me

Don’t let roof problems turn into a nightmare. If you’re a Central Florida homeowner facing a leaking roof, missing shingles, or just aren’t sure if a repair will suffice, turn to the professionals at Castle Roofing Group. We’ve been serving Orlando and Central Florida for almost two decades providing honest assessments and expert workmanship on every project.

We offer a range of roofing services, including thorough roof inspections, skilled repairs, and full roof replacements when needed. Ready to get your roof the care it deserves? Contact Castle Roofing Group today.  You can contact us online or call us at 407-477-2823  for a free inspection and estimate.

Category: Roof Replacement Tags: , , , , , , , No Comments
The Benefits Of Regular Roof Inspections And Maintenance Orlando

The Benefits of Regular Roof Inspections and Maintenance

Orlando Roofing Company If you’re a homeowner, one of the best things you can do to protect your biggest inves... Read More »
How Long Does a Roof Really Last Orlando

How Long Does a Roof Really Last?

Orlando Roofing Company If you are a homeowner, you may wonder how long your roof will last. The answer depends ... Read More »
how roof leaks can ruin your home health florida

How Roof Leaks Can Ruin Your Home & Health

A sturdy and well-maintained roof is crucial for the protection and integrity of your home. However, even the most ... Read More »

Comments are closed.